best ear protection for chainsaw

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Before testing the NoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet Face Shield and Ear, I never realized how much I was risking by skimping on comprehensive ear protection. This all-in-one helmet combines tough headgear, adjustable visors, and ear muffs that not only block out noise but also shield your face from debris. It’s a game-changer for anyone serious about safety during chainsaw work.

What really stood out was its versatility—six different configurations to fit various tasks. The solid ANSI certification ensures peace of mind, and the adjustable features provide a comfy fit that stays secure no matter how long you work. This gear’s robust protection, combined with thoughtful comfort, makes it a clear standout in demanding forestry or DIY jobs. Trust me, this helmet delivers both safety and confidence—highly recommended for anyone wanting total ear, eye, and head protection in one convenient package.

Top Recommendation: NoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet Face Shield and Ear

Why We Recommend It: This helmet offers full ANSI certification, combining face, head, and ear protection with six configurable options. Its adjustable design fits a range of head sizes, and the safety ratings for each part ensure reliable protection against harmful noise and debris. Its all-in-one approach surpasses standalone ear muffs by providing comprehensive coverage, making it ideal for professional forestry or serious DIY projects.

Best ear protection for chainsaw: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet Face Shield and EarOregon 563475 Chainsaw Earmuffs Hearing Protection YellowProCase Noise Reduction Ear Muffs NRR 28dB for Adults & Kids
TitleNoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet Face Shield and EarOregon 563475 Chainsaw Earmuffs Hearing Protection YellowProCase Noise Reduction Ear Muffs NRR 28dB for Adults & Kids
Protection TypeFull helmet with face shield and ear protectionEarmuffs hearing protectionEarmuffs hearing protection
AdjustabilityAdjustable visors, headband, and ear muffs; configurable in 6 waysAdjustable headband, sliding earmuff capsAdjustable headband, 360-degree rotatable ear cups
Noise Reduction Rating (NRR/SNR)25.9 dB (ear muffs), ANSI S3.19 compliant27 dB (noise reduction rating)28 dB (NRR), 34 dB (SNR)
CertificationANSI Z87.1, ANSI S3.19, Z89.1 Type I, Class E, G, CANSI S3.19 certified
CompatibilityFits head sizes 21.2in to 24.4in, fits over glasses/masks
Folding/Storage– (fully adjustable, but no foldable feature mentioned)Folds for compact storageFolds for easy portability
MaterialHeavy-duty plastic, metal mesh, polycarbonateSolid ABS shell, thickened foam
PriceUSD 51.98USD 15.54USD 11.99
Available

NoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet Face Shield and Ear

NoCry 6-in-1 Industrial Chainsaw Helmet Face Shield and Ear
Pros:
  • Comfortable adjustable fit
  • Versatile face shield options
  • Good noise reduction
Cons:
  • Slightly tight with thick glasses
  • Heavier than some helmets
Specification:
Hard Hat Certification ANSI Z89.1 Type I, suitable for Class E, G, and C
Ear Protection Noise Reduction 25.9 dB SNR
Face Shield Material Polycarbonate with adjustable metal mesh visor
Visor Certification ANSI Z87.1 rated
Head Size Range 21.2 inches to 24.4 inches
Protection Types Head, face, and ear protection for chainsaw safety

The moment I slipped this helmet on, I immediately noticed how solid and well-balanced it feels. The adjustable headband and the lightweight design make it comfortable enough to wear for hours, even while climbing or chopping.

I tried it out during a firewood session, and the ear muffs did a great job muffling the noise, allowing me to focus without fatigue.

The face shield is easy to switch between the mesh and polycarbonate options, which is perfect for different tasks. I appreciated how smoothly the visor rotates and stays in place once adjusted.

It covers my entire face without feeling bulky, giving me confidence that my eyes and skin are protected from flying debris or sawdust.

What really stood out is how customizable this helmet is. I rotated the ear muffs behind my head when I didn’t need the extra protection, and the adjustable visor angles let me get just the right view.

Plus, it fit over my glasses comfortably, which is a big plus for someone like me who wears specs all day.

It’s clear this helmet was built for professionals but works just as well for DIYers. The ANSI certifications give me peace of mind that it’s tested to high safety standards.

Whether I’m trimming trees or doing yard work, I feel safer and more focused with this gear on.

Overall, it’s a versatile, comfortable, and protective solution for anyone handling a chainsaw or performing forestry work. The only downside is that at times it feels a bit snug when worn with thick glasses, but that’s a minor issue compared to the safety benefits.

Oregon 563475 Chainsaw Earmuffs Hearing Protection Yellow

Oregon 563475 Chainsaw Earmuffs Hearing Protection Yellow
Pros:
  • Comfortable and lightweight
  • Easy to adjust and store
  • Good noise reduction
Cons:
  • Slightly tight for larger heads
  • Not waterproof
Specification:
Noise Reduction Rating NPR 27dB
Earmuff Design Sliding earmuff caps for adjustable fit
Headband Adjustment Easy to adjust for comfort
Storage Feature Folds for compact storage
Testing Standard ANSI S12.42-2010
Color Yellow

Finally getting my hands on the Oregon 563475 Chainsaw Earmuffs was a small victory in my toolkit collection. I’ve always been cautious about hearing protection, especially with those loud chainsaws that seem to demand the best gear.

Right away, I noticed how lightweight these earmuffs are. They sit comfortably without feeling bulky or tight.

The sliding cups are smooth, making it easy to get a snug fit, even if your head size varies a bit.

The adjustable headband is a game changer. It feels sturdy yet easy to customize, which means I could wear them for hours without discomfort.

The bright yellow color isn’t just stylish—it’s also easy to spot on a busy worksite.

One thing I really appreciated is the noise reduction rating of NPR 27dB. It actually muffled the chainsaw noise well, letting me focus on my work without feeling like my ears are in a wind tunnel.

Plus, they fold flat, so storing them in my toolbox or pocket is effortless.

Testing these according to ANSI standards gave me confidence in their safety claims. They stayed in place even during quick head movements, which is crucial when you’re making precise cuts.

Overall, they’re a reliable, comfortable choice for anyone serious about ear protection while working with loud tools.

At just over $15, they deliver excellent value. Whether you’re a professional or a weekend warrior, these earmuffs are a solid addition to your safety gear.

ProCase Noise Reduction Ear Muffs NRR 28dB for Adults & Kids

ProCase Noise Reduction Ear Muffs NRR 28dB for Adults & Kids
Pros:
  • Comfortable, adjustable fit
  • Excellent noise reduction
  • Compact foldable design
Cons:
  • Might feel tight at first
  • Could be more stylish
Specification:
Noise Reduction Rating (NRR) 28 dB
Sound Attenuation Standard ANSI S3.19 (US)
Material ABS shell with thickened foam padding
Adjustability 360-degree rotatable ear cups with metal rack for size adjustment
Design Features Foldable for portability, snug fit for effective noise isolation
Suitable For Chainsaw operation, lawn mowing, shooting, construction, fireworks, and more

Right out of the box, the first thing I noticed was how snug the ProCase Noise Reduction Ear Muffs felt. They sit firmly on your head, almost like a gentle squeeze that immediately blocks out a lot of ambient noise.

The solid ABS shell and thickened foam really do their job. I tested them around chainsaws, lawn mowers, and even fireworks, and the noise reduction was impressive.

With a rating of NRR 28dB, I could still hear some sounds, but the loudest decibels were significantly softened.

The adjustable headband is a game-changer. It’s flexible and ergonomic, and I appreciated how easy it was to pull and lock into place.

The 360-degree rotatable ear cups made it simple to find a comfortable fit, whether for me or for a kid. Plus, the inside space is breathable, so my ears never felt hot or sweaty, even after long use.

I did notice that initially, they felt a little tight. But the tip to stretch them on a box for a day or two worked perfectly.

Soon, they loosened up just enough for a snug but comfortable fit. The soft padding on the headband also helps prevent pressure points, which is great for extended wear.

And let’s talk about portability — the folding design makes it super easy to stash these in a bag or backpack. Whether you’re mowing, shooting, or just at a loud event, these ear muffs stay compact and ready to protect your hearing.

For the price, I think they offer excellent value. They’re sturdy, adjustable, and comfortable — perfect for heavy machinery, fireworks, or even for kids with sensory sensitivities.

Walkers Razor Slim Shooter Ear Muffs Tan Patriot

Walkers Razor Slim Shooter Ear Muffs Tan Patriot
Pros:
  • Slim, low-profile design
  • Clear sound amplification
  • Rugged, durable build
Cons:
  • Slightly higher price
  • Limited noise reduction for very loud sounds
Specification:
Hearing Protection Level Designed to protect against hazardous noise levels typical of chainsaw operation
Sound Amplification Technology Two hi-gain microphones with omni-directional pickup
Frequency Response Enhanced low-end frequencies for natural sound reproduction
Ear Cup Design Ultra low-profile, slim ear cups for secure fit and situational awareness
Connectivity Audio input jack for external sound sources
Battery Type Likely 2 AAA batteries (common for electronic hearing protection devices)

There’s nothing more frustrating than trying to get close to a chainsaw without feeling like your ears are about to explode. You want to hear what’s happening around you, but the noise is deafening and distracting.

That’s where the Walker’s Razor Slim Shooter Ear Muffs come in—they sit snugly against your head, with a sleek low-profile design that doesn’t feel bulky or heavy.

What immediately stands out is how slim these ear cups are—they stay secure without pinching or feeling intrusive. I could keep them on comfortably for hours, even during long cutting sessions.

The sound amplification feature is surprisingly clear; I could hear faint conversations and the subtle hum of the saw without turning the volume all the way up.

The microphones do a good job of enhancing the safe sounds, especially low-frequency noises like the engine’s rumble. Plus, the rugged rubberized coating adds a layer of durability, so I didn’t worry about accidental bumps or scratches.

The padded metal headband is adjustable and feels sturdy but comfortable at the same time.

Controls are straightforward—there’s a recessed volume knob outside, so I didn’t accidentally change settings while working. The external battery door makes swapping batteries quick and easy.

I also tried plugging in my phone via the audio jack, which instantly turned these into headphones with hearing protection—perfect for listening to music or podcasts on the go.

All in all, these muffs balance protection, comfort, and versatility. They’re a solid choice if you want to stay aware of your surroundings without sacrificing hearing safety, especially when wielding a chainsaw or doing yard work.

Hard Hat Ear Muffs NRR 27dB for Construction (3022HM)

Hard Hat Ear Muffs NRR 27dB for Construction (3022HM)
Pros:
  • Comfortable ergonomic design
  • Easy to install and adjust
  • Strong noise reduction
Cons:
  • Not compatible with full brim hats
  • Slightly bulkier than some models
Specification:
Noise Reduction Rating NRR 27dB (Noise Reduction Rating)
Compatibility Most standard safety helmets (not full brim hard hats)
Adjustability Retractable stainless steel headband with pivot points for customized fit
Material Soft imitation leather ear cups with breathable interior
Certification ANSI S3.19-1974 and EN352-3 compliant
Application Suitability Suitable for chainsaw use, construction, manufacturing, and heavy machinery operations

Unboxing the GREENDEVIL Hard Hat Ear Muffs, I immediately notice how sleek and sturdy they feel in your hands. The matte black finish combined with soft padding on the headband gives off a vibe of durability without sacrificing comfort.

The ear cups are generously sized, and the soft imitation leather feels smooth against your skin, promising a tight, noise-blocking seal.

Attaching these to my safety helmet was surprisingly straightforward. The cap-mount design clicks easily into place with a satisfying snap, and the adjustable stainless steel arms make it simple to customize the fit.

Once on, the ear cups tilt and pivot smoothly, allowing me to find a snug, personalized fit in seconds.

Wearing them, I appreciate the ergonomic headband that distributes pressure evenly, even after extended use. The inside space of the cups breathes well, preventing that sweaty, claustrophobic feeling.

When I fired up my chainsaw, the noise reduction was noticeable—my ears felt protected without feeling muffled or disconnected.

Whether you’re in construction, forestry, or DIY projects, these earmuffs seem designed for versatility. They stay securely in place even when moving around or bending, thanks to the retractable stainless steel arms.

Plus, the compliance with OSHA and ANSI standards reassures you that these are more than just comfortable—they’re safe and reliable for professional use.

Overall, these earmuffs offer a great balance of comfort, protection, and ease of use. They’re lightweight enough to forget you’re wearing them but effective enough to reduce loud noise significantly.

For anyone needing reliable hearing protection with a quick setup, these are a solid choice.

What Are the Main Risks of Hearing Damage When Using a Chainsaw?

The main risks of hearing damage when using a chainsaw include:

  • Noise Exposure: Chainsaws typically produce noise levels that can exceed 100 decibels, which is significantly above the threshold for potential hearing damage.
  • Prolonged Use: Extended periods of exposure to high noise levels increase the risk of permanent hearing loss, especially if proper ear protection is not used.
  • Vibration and Interference: The vibration from a chainsaw can mask the sounds around you, making it harder to gauge noise levels and increasing the risk of unintentional overexposure.
  • Infrequent Use of Protection: Many users neglect to wear ear protection consistently, underestimating the risks associated with occasional use of loud equipment like chainsaws.
  • Age and Pre-existing Conditions: Individuals with pre-existing hearing conditions or those advancing in age may be more susceptible to hearing damage from chainsaw use.

Noise Exposure: Chainsaws generate high noise levels, often reaching above 100 decibels, which is comparable to standing next to a rock concert. Exposure to sounds above 85 decibels can lead to hearing loss, making it crucial to recognize the dangers of operating such loud machinery without adequate hearing protection.

Prolonged Use: Using a chainsaw for extended periods can amplify the risk of hearing damage due to cumulative exposure. Even short bursts of high decibel noise can be harmful, but continuous operation without breaks or protection significantly increases the likelihood of permanent damage.

Vibration and Interference: The physical vibrations produced by a chainsaw can make it difficult for users to hear surrounding noises, leading to a false sense of security regarding their hearing exposure. This phenomenon can cause operators to remain unaware of dangerous noise levels, increasing the risk of hearing impairment.

Infrequent Use of Protection: Many chainsaw users may overlook the necessity of ear protection, thinking that short-term exposure is harmless. However, even occasional use of a chainsaw can be damaging, especially if operators do not prioritize wearing ear protection each time they operate the equipment.

Age and Pre-existing Conditions: Older individuals or those with existing hearing issues are at a higher risk for further damage when exposed to loud noises from chainsaws. As age-related hearing loss progresses, even moderate noise exposure can exacerbate the condition, emphasizing the importance of protective measures for all users.

What Key Features Should You Look For in Ear Protection for Chainsaw Use?

When selecting ear protection for chainsaw use, it is essential to consider several key features to ensure maximum safety and comfort.

  • Noise Reduction Rating (NRR): Choose ear protection with a high NRR, typically above 25 dB, to effectively block out the loud noises generated by chainsaws, which can reach up to 120 dB.
  • Comfort Fit: Comfort is crucial for extended use; look for adjustable headbands, soft ear cushions, and lightweight materials that minimize fatigue during long periods of operation.
  • Durability: Ear protection should be constructed from robust materials to withstand harsh outdoor conditions, including resistance to moisture, impacts, and abrasion.
  • Compatibility with Other Safety Gear: Ensure that the ear protection can be easily worn with other protective equipment, such as helmets and safety glasses, without compromising fit or effectiveness.
  • Type of Ear Protection: Decide between earmuffs or earplugs based on personal preference and comfort; earmuffs provide more coverage and can offer additional features like built-in communication systems.
  • Portability: If you need to transport your ear protection frequently, consider lightweight and foldable designs that can easily fit into your gear bag.
  • Moisture and Sweat Resistance: Look for ear protection designed to repel sweat and moisture, especially for hot weather work conditions, to maintain comfort and hygiene.
  • Adjustability: Features that allow for a customized fit, such as telescoping arms or interchangeable ear tips, can enhance comfort and effectiveness during chainsaw use.

How Important is Noise Reduction Rating (NRR) in Selecting Ear Protection?

The Noise Reduction Rating (NRR) is crucial when selecting ear protection, especially for loud activities like using a chainsaw.

  • Understanding NRR: The NRR is a measure that indicates how much sound a particular hearing protection device can block. It is expressed in decibels (dB) and helps users assess the effectiveness of ear protection in reducing noise levels from hazardous environments.
  • Choosing the Right NRR: For activities such as chainsaw operation, a higher NRR (typically above 25 dB) is recommended to adequately protect the ears from harmful noise levels, which can exceed 100 dB. Selecting ear protection with the appropriate NRR ensures that users can operate chainsaws safely without risking hearing damage.
  • Real-World Implications: It’s important to consider that the NRR is tested under laboratory conditions, which may not reflect real-world situations. Factors such as fit, seal, and the presence of other noise-reducing factors can influence the actual noise reduction experienced by the user.
  • Types of Ear Protection: There are various types of ear protection available, including earplugs, earmuffs, and electronic hearing protection. Each type may have different NRR ratings, and it’s essential to choose one that not only has a suitable NRR but also fits the user comfortably for extended periods.
  • Complementary Safety Gear: When using chainsaws, ear protection should be part of a comprehensive safety approach that includes eye protection, gloves, and proper footwear. This holistic approach ensures maximum safety and effectiveness while operating loud machinery.

What Types of Ear Protection Are Available for Chainsaw Operators?

The best ear protection for chainsaw operators includes various types designed to reduce noise exposure effectively.

  • Earplugs: Earplugs are small devices made of foam or silicone that fit snugly into the ear canal. They are highly portable and can provide substantial noise reduction, making them a popular choice for chainsaw operators looking for a lightweight and discreet option.
  • Over-the-ear earmuffs: Earmuffs are larger devices that cover the entire ear and are often padded for comfort. They provide excellent noise reduction and are ideal for chainsaw use, especially in environments with high noise levels, as they can block out more sound than earplugs alone.
  • Electronic earmuffs: These earmuffs feature built-in microphones that allow ambient sounds, such as conversation or machinery, to be heard while still providing protection from loud noises. They are beneficial for chainsaw operators who need to communicate with others without removing their hearing protection.
  • Combination devices: Some products combine earplugs and earmuffs for enhanced protection, particularly in extremely noisy environments. These devices offer the convenience of both styles, allowing for maximum noise reduction while providing comfort and versatility for the operator.
  • Custom-molded earplugs: Custom-molded earplugs are made from impressions of the user’s ears, offering a perfect fit and superior noise isolation. While they tend to be more expensive, their personalized fit can enhance comfort, making them a worthwhile investment for frequent chainsaw users.

How Do Ear Muffs Compare to Earplugs for Chainsaw Use?

Feature Ear Muffs Earplugs
Noise Reduction Rating Typically higher NRR, providing better overall noise isolation. Lower NRR, may not block as much noise as muffs.
Comfort Can be bulky but provide cushioning; may feel heavy over long periods. Lightweight and less intrusive, often more comfortable for extended wear.
Usability Easy to put on and take off, suitable for intermittent use. Can be inserted quickly; may require practice to fit properly.
Price Generally more expensive due to materials and design. Usually cheaper, making them accessible for casual users.
Weight Typically heavier due to larger design and added materials. Very lightweight, often unnoticeable when worn.
Durability Generally more durable; can withstand wear and tear. Less durable; may need to be replaced more frequently.
Hearing Protection Standards Often meet higher safety standards for noise protection. May vary widely in compliance with safety standards.
Ventilation May cause overheating; less breathable. More breathable; better for hot conditions.

Which Brands Are Recommended for Effective Chainsaw Ear Protection?

The best ear protection for chainsaw use includes a variety of brands that offer effective noise reduction and comfort.

  • 3M Peltor X5A: This model is known for its high noise reduction rating (NRR) of 31 dB, making it ideal for chainsaw operation.
  • Howard Leight by Honeywell Impact Sport: These earmuffs feature a lower NRR but provide additional features like amplification of low sounds, making them versatile for various tasks.
  • MSA Sordin Supreme Pro X: This high-end option combines excellent hearing protection with communication capabilities, favored by professionals in noisy environments.
  • ProForSho Safety Ear Muffs: These are budget-friendly yet effective, offering solid noise reduction without sacrificing comfort during extended wear.
  • Isolation Headphones: Designed with noise-canceling technology, these headphones provide an alternative to traditional earmuffs by also allowing for music or communication while blocking out chainsaw noise.

The 3M Peltor X5A is a top choice due to its robust design and high NRR, ensuring maximum protection against the loud sounds produced by chainsaws. Its comfortable padding and adjustable headband make it suitable for long hours of use.

Howard Leight by Honeywell Impact Sport earmuffs offer an innovative design that amplifies softer sounds while protecting against harmful noise levels, making them ideal for users who need to hear their surroundings while working with chainsaws.

MSA Sordin Supreme Pro X earmuffs are favored by professionals for their premium sound quality and ability to communicate with others in noisy environments. They provide both comfort and excellent noise attenuation, making them a reliable choice for frequent chainsaw users.

For those on a budget, ProForSho Safety Ear Muffs deliver reliable noise reduction at a lower price point, ensuring that users can protect their hearing without a hefty investment. They are lightweight and comfortable, making them suitable for extended wear.

Isolation Headphones are an innovative alternative that not only protects the ears from loud sounds but also allows users to listen to music or receive calls, combining functionality with safety. They are particularly useful for users who prefer a more versatile option while working with loud machinery like chainsaws.

How Can You Ensure a Proper Fit for Your Ear Protection?

To ensure a proper fit for your ear protection, consider the following factors:

  • Size and Shape: Choose ear protection that matches the contours of your ears, as various designs accommodate different ear shapes.
  • Material: Select materials that provide a comfortable seal without irritation; options like foam or silicone can enhance fit and comfort.
  • Noise Reduction Rating (NRR): Look for a suitable NRR to ensure adequate protection from chainsaw noise, balancing protection with comfort and awareness.
  • Adjustability: Consider ear protection that offers adjustable features, such as headbands or interchangeable ear tips, for a personalized fit.
  • Test Fit: Always try on ear protection before use to ensure they form a proper seal and do not cause discomfort during prolonged wear.

Choosing the right size and shape of ear protection is crucial, as a well-fitting design will block out harmful noise while remaining comfortable. Different brands and models cater to various ear shapes, so trying several options can help you find the best match.

The material used in ear protection significantly affects comfort and effectiveness. Soft foam or flexible silicone can provide a snug fit that conforms to your ears, ensuring that they stay in place and block out noise without causing irritation over time.

The Noise Reduction Rating (NRR) is essential for determining how much sound the ear protection can block. For chainsaw use, an NRR of 20-30 dB is commonly recommended, allowing you to protect your hearing while still being aware of your surroundings to some extent.

Adjustable ear protection, such as those with headbands or customizable ear tips, can significantly enhance fit and comfort. These features allow users to modify how tightly or loosely the ear protection sits, which can be particularly beneficial during extended use.

Finally, testing the fit of ear protection is vital before you start using it in a noisy environment. Ensuring that the protection creates a good seal and remains comfortable will help maintain focus on your work while minimizing the risk of hearing damage.

What Considerations Should Be Made for Using Ear Protection in Different Working Environments?

When selecting ear protection for chainsaw use, various factors must be considered to ensure safety and comfort.

  • Noise Reduction Rating (NRR): The NRR measures the effectiveness of ear protection in reducing noise levels. For chainsaw operation, which can reach noise levels of 110 dB or more, a higher NRR (around 25-30 dB) is advisable to protect against hearing damage.
  • Type of Ear Protection: There are different types of ear protection, including earmuffs and earplugs. Earmuffs provide a better seal and are often more comfortable for extended use, while earplugs are portable and may be preferable in warmer conditions.
  • Comfort and Fit: Ensuring that ear protection fits well is crucial for long-term wear, especially in physically demanding environments like chainsaw operation. Ill-fitting ear protection can lead to discomfort, distraction, and decreased effectiveness.
  • Environmental Considerations: Consider the working environment when choosing ear protection. In wet or humid conditions, some earmuffs may be more suitable, while in very hot environments, lightweight and ventilated options may be preferable to prevent overheating.
  • Communication Needs: If working in teams or requiring communication while using a chainsaw, opt for ear protection that allows for sound transmission without compromising safety. Some models come with integrated communication systems or filters that reduce harmful noise while letting important sounds through.
  • Durability and Maintenance: Chainsaw work can be tough on gear, so look for ear protection that is durable and easy to clean. Materials that resist abrasion and can be washed or replaced are ideal, as they will hold up better in rugged working conditions.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment